Zitationsvorschlag

Dimroth, Christine, Andorno, Cecilia und Benazzo, Sandra: When Discourse Elicitation Tasks Go Dialogue: Introducing Entities in French, German, and Italian, in Gerwien, Johannes, Marberg, Ines und Nicolaisen, Kristian (Hrsg.): Die kognitive Perspektive: Wie Menschen über die Welt sprechen.  Festschrift zu Ehren von Christiane von Stutterheim, Heidelberg: Heidelberg University Publishing, 2024, S. 23–58. https://doi.org/10.17885/heiup.1292.c20248

Identifier (Buch)

ISBN 978-3-96822-162-5 (PDF)
ISBN 978-3-96822-163-2 (Softcover)

Veröffentlicht

12.09.2024

Autor/innen

Christine Dimroth, Cecilia Andorno , Sandra Benazzo

When Discourse Elicitation Tasks Go Dialogue

Introducing Entities in French, German, and Italian

Abstract This paper presents first results from a study on oral picture de­scription dialogues produced by native speakers of French, German, and Italian. The aim is to find out how speakers of these languages introduce the objects they want to talk about so that their interlocutors can identify and lo­calise them while building a coherent representation of the picture. In doing so, we are tying in with work on the description of spatial configurations by Christiane von Stutterheim and colleagues (Carroll & von Stutterheim, 1993; von Stutterheim, 1997a), who used a similar method, keeping the stimulus and the procedure constant while running the task with speakers of different languages. When compared with the highly sophisticated non-verbal data elicitation techniques used by the Heidelberg team in their more recent work on event cognition, asking someone to describe a picture at their own pace seems quite a trivial approach. We are convinced, however, that it is worth­while to go back to (some of) the roots, building on earlier work and at the same time changing a parameter that has quite some impact on the course of events: Instead of quasi-monologues with a rather passive addressee, we are studying dialogues in which two speakers are acting at eye level when describing and comparing mutually unknown spatial configurations. The reconstructed Quaestio (Klein & von Stutterheim, 1987) that is assumed to support a speaker’s selection and organisation of information in a mono­logue might be locally overwritten in a dialogue when an interlocutor’s real questions or statements alter the information flow.

Keywords Discourse, dialogue, typology, information structure, spatial description, entity introduction and contrast